Thursday, May 2, 2013

Justice minister ford reply 4/9/2012

FROM THE OFFICE OF THE JUSTICE MINISTER Departmentof Justice Minister’s Office BlockB,
Castle Buildings Stormont Estate Ballymiscaw
Belfast BT43SG Tel:02890528121
Ourref:C0R184312012

Dear .......!
Thank you for your email of 15 August which raises concerns in respect of Mrs Marian McGlinchey.

You have asked me to release Mrs McGlinchey from custody on compassionate grounds so that she can avail of medical treatment. You have also asked me to clarify whether I have sole responsibility for this provision or if my powers are subservient to those of the Secretary of State in this matter.

Healthcare provision Responsibility for the provision of prisoner healthcare in Northern Ireland lies with the Department of Health,Social Services and Public Safety (DHSSPS) and,through the SouthEastern Health and Social CareTrust (SET),that Department is required to provide healthcare arrangements comparable with those available in the community.As Minister of Justice for Northern Ireland,in partnership with colleagues in the SET,I am committed to ensuring that the specific health and social care needs of prisoners in custody are met.Mrs McGlinchey is no exception.

Mrs McGlinchey was transferred to an in-patient setting under the care of the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust on 22June.The decision to transfer Mrs McGlinchey was taken following the clinical assessment of her condition by the SET and in the interests of her health.For as long as she remains in this in-patient setting, the Belfast Trust is responsible for the provision of all her medical needs.

The DHSSPS has confirmed that Mrs McGlinchey is receiving the appropriate level of treatment for her condition.

Release from custody on compassionate grounds Article7 of the Life Sentences (NorthernIreland) Order2001 (LSO) gives the Department of Justice the power to release life sentence prisoners on compassionate grounds,but only if it is satisfied that‘ exceptional circumstances’ exist to justify that release.

However,you should note that the Northern Ireland Act1998 (Devolution of Policing and Justice Functions) Order 2010 (SI2010/976) amended Article7 of the LSO to give the Secretary of State the power to direct that a prisoner should not be released on compassionate grounds without his agreement if  his decision to make such a direction is arrived at on the grounds of protected information’ .
‘Protected information ’is defined as meaning information which if disclosed may,in the opinion of the Secretary of State,be against the interests of national security.

In coming to the decision to transfer Mrs McGlinchey to an in-patient setting under the care of the Belfast Trust,I considered all the powers available to me which provide for compassionate release,temporary release and prisoner transfers. In light of the  evidence,after reviewing the various options and having taken both clinical advice and the security and public protection considerations applying to her case into account,I concluded that the grounds for compassionate release do not exist in this case but that Mrs  McGlinchey should instead be transferred to a secure facility for treatment under Section16 of the Prison Act (NI) 1953.
I remain of the view that Mrs McGlinchey is currently receiving an appropriate level of treatment under the care of the Belfast Trust and I have received no further medical advice from the Belfast Trust to demonstrate that sufficient reasons exist to release Mrs McGlinchey on compassionate grounds

Parole Commissioners Review
All life sentence prisoners remain on licence for life.They can be recalled at any time if they breach the conditions of their licence.The Secretary of State has the power to recall life licensees to prison if he believes that they have become a risk to the public and if his grounds for believing that are based on ‘protected information’.

The Secretary of State’s decision to revoke Mrs McGlinchey’s life licence and recall her to custody was taken on foot of a recommendation by the Parole Commissioners that the risk of serious harm posed by her had increased significantly.

The Secretary of State’s decision is now the subject of a statutory review by the Parole Commissioners. If the Parole Commissioners are satisfied that it is no longer necessary for the protection of the public from serious harm that she should be detained,they may direct Mrs McGlinchey’s release.The decision of the Parole Commissioners is final and cannot be overruled.I should also point out that this review is wholly out with the remit of the Department of Justice.

I trust that this addresses your concerns.

David Ford MLA

Department of Justice

Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Draft letter to secretary of state

Please see attached DRAFT LETTER TO SECRETARY OF STATE PLEASE DO NOT COPY VERBATIM BUT PUT YOUR OWN CONCERNS IN AND YOUR OWN PERSONALITY AND KNOWLEDGE

email-post-fax details on NIO Website.
Thank you all.

Rt.Hon Theresa Villiers

I am writing to yourself as secretary of state for northern Ireland to express my concern at the ongoing detention without trial or due process of INSERT NAME. I am sure you have availed yourself of the details of the incarceration of Marian Price and the case.

It is unfortunate your predecessor Owen Patterson was not forthcoming with details of some questions which have been asked by members of the public interested in human rights or open with other concerned representatives groups. Despite several attempts only one cursory form letter was received. Department of justice minister David Ford was prompt in replying to questions relating to the detention of Marian Price.

Please if you would be kind enough to answer or indicate how your office will endeavour to proceed in a just manner,respecting human rights to the following :-

1. Please could you detail the legislation INSERT NAME now finds herself/himself detained without trial. Are there matters still outstanding to be settled in court.

2. I appreciate details are privileged by national security issues, however are you able to explain if you schedule regular reviews of her/his case taking into account mitigating factors for release?

3. There are obvious human rights concerns including the European convention of human rights including a right to a fair trial,due process,the right to life and right to be free from inhumane,degrading treatment and torture. Are you able to re-assure myself that these rights are being respected?

4. The Good Friday Agreement was supposed to replace draconian measures such as internment to herald a new era in politics, social and economic life for the province looking forward to a peaceful future. Does the detention INSERT NAME advance a peaceful future? Or does it demonstrate to many nothing has changed, that a true path to peace has yet to be found?

I look forward to your prompt response to this in due course.

Regards

YOUR NAME